About retracted papers


Prominent Scientist Retracts CBD Paper and Spreads Misinformation

1.Overview
2022Papers published in 「Cannabidiol (Cbd) From Non-Cannabis Plants: Myth or Reality?」 was a study that examined the potential of cannabidiol (CBD) to be obtained from plants other than cannabis.
This paper, inter alia,He categorically denied that Kriya Hops was a scam and claimed that there was no scientific basis for the existence of CBD.
However, this thesis was later retracted. It was pointed out that the reason for the retraction was that "the original information was false."
We will explain the background and impact of this paper retraction, as well as the misinformation that spreads in Japan, based on facts.

2. About The Author
The authors of this paper are highly respected researchers in their respective fields.
#Giovanni Appendino
Prominent Italian natural products chemist
He has published numerous papers on bioactive compounds and cannabinoids derived from plants
# Orazio Taglialatera = Scafati (Orazio Taglialatela-Scafati)
Professor of Medicinal Botany, University of Naples
Research biologically active substances derived from marine natural products, phytocannabinoids, and microorganisms
#Eduardo Muñoz Professor of Immunology, University of Córdoba, Spain
He has studied the anti-inflammatory and immunomodulatory effects of CBD and has published numerous papers

3. Contents of the retracted paper
In this paper, the following claims were developed.
#Research Claims Kriya Hops Contain CBD Is a Scam
#Insufficient evidence for the presence of CBD in plants other than cannabis
#Reports on hop-derived CBD are lacking in science

The paper was published in 2022 but was retracted in January 2025.
Click on the image to see the official information of the paper.

4. Reasons for withdrawal
The authors retracted the paper for the following reasons:

#It turns out that part of the paper was based on a web article that contained false information
#Acknowledged that the description of Bomi Joseph was inaccurate and apologized
#Without sufficient scientific verification, a conclusive assessment of Kriya Hops as a "scam" was made

5. Kriya Hops Patents
Although Kriya Hops was denied in the paper, the following scientific evidence actually exists.
#Kriya Hops has officially obtained plant patents (USPP31,477P3, etc.)
#Anti-cannabidiol antibodies (CBD detection technology) are also patented
#Even before the paper was retracted, there was a mention of Kriya Hops in patent data and research papers

As long as the patent is obtained, the claim that it does not exist is contrary to the facts.


6. Dissemination of misinformation in Japan
Despite the retraction of the paper, there is a situation where misinformation about Kriya Hops is being deliberately spread in Japan.
Green Zone Japan translated the information in the United States in an article on June 15, 2019
Later, during the trial, the article was temporarily locked so that it could not be viewed by the public.
It will be open to the public again after the trial is over.

I have made inquiries to the Japan company that I was dealing with at the time I wrote the article,
We have not contacted Bomi Joseph.
In other words, it is an article based on only one point of view.

The URL is as follows.
You can judge for yourself.

http://www.greenzonejapan.com/2019/06/15/hopcbd/
http://www.gereenzoneiapan.com/2020/02/29/hopcbd-2/

▶ Experience the difference between CBD developed by doctors

"I want to deliver truly reliable CBD to the world."